Skip to main content

Match of the Day pundit calls for West Brom ban after 'awful' Chesterfield incident

West Bromwich Albion news from BirminghamLive brings you more reaction to the dramatic FA Cup third round tie at Chesterfield

Danny Murphy
Danny Murphy highlighted an incident involving West Brom's Brandon Thomas-Asante(Image: Match of the Day/BBC Sport)

Match of the Day pundit Danny Murphy reckons West Bromwich Albion hero Brandon Thomas-Asante could be facing a ban following an alleged elbowing incident during the dramatic FA Cup third round tie at Chesterfield.


Thomas-Asante headed a last-gasp equaliser to secure a 3-3 draw and spare West Brom blushes after they looked to be heading out of the competition against National League opposition. The same player had given Albion an early lead at the Technique Stadium but Tyrone Williams soon equalised for the Spireites.


Karlan Grant put Carlos Corberan's side in front again in the 17th minute before Armando Dobra struck twice late in the first half to turn the match around. Just when it looked like Chesterfield had done enough to hold out and reach the fourth round for the first time in more than 25 years, Thomas-Asante struck again deep into added time to secure a replay.

Article continues below

READ MORE: Carlos Corberan's eyes are opened as West Brom are dealt a fresh worry

READ MORE: West Brom player ratings v Chesterfield: Thomas-Asante saves dismal Albion


It was a painful ending for the Derbyshire hosts, and Match of the Day later highlighted an incident involving Thomas-Asante, which took place shortly before the late leveller. He appeared to elbow opposition player Jeff King as the pair tussled for the ball, leaving the Chesterfield man on the floor.

No action was taken by match officials at the time - but Murphy believes the Albion player may not escape without punishment. Asked by presenter Mark Chapman if things could have been different had VAR been in use, the former Liverpool and Fulham midfielder replied: "Would have been, 100%. It's an awful elbow.


"He gets away with one - well he probably won't get away with it tomorrow or Monday or whenever they have a look at it. And of course, he gets away with it and what happens? We've seen it many times before over the years, a couple of minutes later he gets the equaliser and deprives Chesterfield of a place in the next round.


"Brandon Thomas-Asante was actually one of their best players. He played really well, and he's let himself down with that - but he's probably going to face a ban."

Do you agree with Murphy? Let us know in the comments section


READ NEXT


Carlos Corberan learned 'magic lesson' as West Brom fringe players struggle

Carlos Corberan reveals stance on West Brom's off-field loan turmoil

The unsung heroes helping West Brom stay a step ahead of their rivals

Article continues below

Play-offs, takeover saga & protests: Our West Brom predictions for 2023

Fresh details emerge over £20m MSD loan to West Brom

Follow Birmingham Live:


West Bromwich Albion FCBrandon Thomas-AsanteBBCFA Cup
reach logo

At Reach and across our entities we and our partners use information collected through cookies and other identifiers from your device to improve experience on our site, analyse how it is used and to show personalised advertising. You can opt out of the sale or sharing of your data, at any time clicking the "Do Not Sell or Share my Data" button at the bottom of the webpage. Please note that your preferences are browser specific. Use of our website and any of our services represents your acceptance of the use of cookies and consent to the practices described in our Privacy Notice and Cookie Notice.