Skip to main content

Benni McCarthy got £200k fine for getting fat – and shredding weight made him even worse

The current Manchester United first team coach is working with some of their paciest attackers, but he was once fined and told to slim down by West ham, and it made him slower!

Benni McCarthy joined Erik ten Hag's coaching staff last summer
Benni McCarthy at Old Trafford in pre-season(Image: Manchester United via Getty Images)

Manchester United's attack, though lacking recently, has got to be revered for it's pace.


Marcus Rashford is no slouch, and both Alejandro Garnacho and Rasmus Hojlund have recorded some of the top speeds in the league in 2023. Bringing in Benni McCarthy as a coach last year may have turned some heads, as near the end of his career, it's safe to say pace wasn't exactly a strong point of the the man who won the Champions League with Jose Mourinho's Porto.


Unbelievably, it was actually after McCarthy lost a lot of his weight whilst at West Ham that it was deemed his pace was sub-par for the Premier League.


READ MORE: Benni McCarthy lifts the lid on Man Utd training under 'frightening' Erik ten Hag

READ MORE: Marcus Rashford slams 'malicious' rumours he could be leaving Man Utd

Captain Bruno Fernandes praised the South African last year for his influence on the squad, he said: “He was a quality player and is a quality manager. We do many drills, from finishing to headers to the stuff he was doing when he was playing. It can help us score some goals."

Article continues below

McCarthy never lost his goal-scoring touch after leaving the Hammers, bagging 10 goals in just 24 appearances for Orlando Pirates back in his homeland, but his pace is something that was ultimately lost.

West Ham boss Avram Grant said at the time, that after losing this weight and slimming down from the 15st he was reported to have weighed, McCarthy had slowed down.

How good was Benni McCarthy? Let us know in the comments section


West Ham United's Benni McCarthy stands dejected
McCarthy's spell at West Ham is probably one he'd like to forget(Image: PA)

He said: "He reached the targets, but I think that affected his movement; he's a very good player and one of the best finishers in training that I have ever seen, but now we need players with movement and the advantage of being quick, and we have others."

McCarthy's time at Blackburn was one that ended due to weight issues too, specifically after clashes between him and then Rovers head coach Sam Allardyce. In 2009, McCarthy failed to meet weight targets set by Allardyce and was also left out of South Africa's World Cup squad after it was reported that his body fat had reached 25%, double what's expected from an elite athlete.


Blackburn's Benni McCarthy cheers boss Sam Allardyce by scoring
Benni spent the best part of four years in Blackburn, playing over 100 times

Blackburn axed the ace as well, and then after joining West Ham, he was given a £38,000 fine every time he failed to reach weight loss goals, which saw him rack up around £200,000 in fines. Even after reaching his goals, he was told he was too slow – poor Benni!

His agent at the time, Rob Moore, said: "He wants to play and is not a guy who wants to sit around and collect his cheque. He's at the level of fitness and weight the club prescribed, and they are happy with that. But he is 33 years old, and we have to be realistic."


Get all the sport you could ever ask for
This article contains affiliate links, we will receive a commission on any sales we generate from it. Learn more
Content Image
£22 a month
Sky
Get it here

Sky Sports is bringing you 500 live football games to watch, as well access to Cricket, Golf, F1, Boxing, NFL, NBA and more across eight dedicated channels. Sky Sports is the only way to watch all the action this year.

Benni's now been tasked with handling the pace of United's attacking line and developing Rasmus Hojlund into the ruthless finisher that McCarthy was in his prime.

McCarthy told South African radio station 947 about the sheer amount of work that goes on behind the scenes from the coaching staff at United, he said: "Both my jobs as a coach at Cape Town City and AmaZulu, if you put them together, it doesn't come close to the workload that's being done at Man United.

Article continues below
Benni McCarthy revealed what it's like to work under 'frightening' Erik ten Hag
McCarthy is now working alongside Erik ten Hag(Image: Getty Images)

“It is relentless, but that is expected because of the levels and the amount of world class players you deal with on a daily basis. We've got to be prepared every single day. At seven in the morning we're in the office, when you see the success Man United have everywhere in the world... We are like superheroes."

Follow Daily Star:



Premier LeagueWeight LossWest Ham FCBlackburn Rovers FCManchester United FC
reach logo

At Reach and across our entities we and our partners use information collected through cookies and other identifiers from your device to improve experience on our site, analyse how it is used and to show personalised advertising. You can opt out of the sale or sharing of your data, at any time clicking the "Do Not Sell or Share my Data" button at the bottom of the webpage. Please note that your preferences are browser specific. Use of our website and any of our services represents your acceptance of the use of cookies and consent to the practices described in our Privacy Notice and Cookie Notice.