Skip to main content
Daily Record

Michael Stewart explodes as penalty to Rangers deja vu sees Celtic land familiar 'collision' defence

The raging pundit was left baffled by the decision to punish Alistair Johnston at Ibrox.

Fuming Michael Stewart has been sent into a fury over a Rangers penalty decision after Celtic star Alistair Johnston was punished on derby day.


Fabio Silva went down in the box following a challenge from the right-back - which initially saw referee John Beaton book the Rangers star for simulation. However, VAR would intervene and the man in the middle would be sent to the monitor to review the incident. He then pointed to the spot - allowing James Taverner to make it 2-1 and fire the Light Blues back into the game during the 3-3 thriller.


But Stewart was left in disbelief by the match officials as he let rip on BBC Sportscene. He initially said: "In this instance, you can see quite clearly that Alistair Johnston gets the ball. He wins it. He (Silva) goes to the deck far too easily. It's not a penalty kick - he wins the ball. I don't know what VAR is looking at. You can see it in real time. Alistair Johnston wins the ball."


READ MORE: Why Rangers penalty was given despite Alistair Johnston ball contact as IFAB rules offer 2 point Celtic explainerREAD MORE: What the Rangers vs Celtic pundits said as celebrations earn 'old school' swipe and TikTok jibe gets Kris Boyd approval

A still image was then shown by VAR of the challenge, sparking a heated rant from Stewart. He said: "There is no point in looking at that. That is an incident after the ball has been won.

"Yes, there is a coming together, but he has won the ball. This is beyond belief. You can see it in real time. There is no justification. He wins the ball. There is a coming together, this happens all the time in football. You can see it in real-time, there is no foul to be given."

Article continues below

It follows Stewart being sent into meltdown during Rangers clash with Hibs. Nectarios Triantis jumped to head a corner away from danger but was involved in a collision with Ibrox defender John Souttar - who was attacking the ball. Referee David Dickinson initially waved play on before Andrew Dallas in the VAR room sent the man in the middle to the pitchside monitor.

During last weekend's fixture, Stewart said: "Ok, there is a collision but that's not a penalty kick. If you are giving a penalty for that, I mean give up! The ball is going over his head and Triantis is trying to jump for it, and he has got a booking and a yellow card against him."

Follow Daily Record:


BBCRangers FCMichael StewartScottish PremiershipHibernian FCCeltic FCFabio SilvaAlistair Johnston
reach logo

At Reach and across our entities we and our partners use information collected through cookies and other identifiers from your device to improve experience on our site, analyse how it is used and to show personalised advertising. You can opt out of the saleor sharing of your data, at any time clicking the "Do Not Sell or Share my Data" button at the bottom of the webpage. Please note that your preferences are browser specific. Use of our website and any of our services represents your acceptance of the use of cookies and consent to the practices described in our Privacy Notice and Privacy Notice.