Skip to main content
Daily Record

Neil Critchley rages at Hearts 'VAR fiasco' behind Ross County collapse as he makes defiant penalty claim

A late fight back saw the Staggies claim a point at Tynecastle

(Image: SNS Group)

Neil Critchley insists Hearts were denied a stonewall penalty by VAR at 2-0 up - but still blamed his players for the spectacular late collapse to Ross County.

The Tynecastle boss was left shaking his head at both referee Ross Hardie’s about-turn for the spot-kick and his players' failure to prevent a 97th and 99th minute collapse. Critchley, angry at the lack of game management in those final moments, said: “We were comfortable at 2-0, and the game was over really. They hadn’t really threatened our goal, so we should have seen the game out.


“It’s just two crazy moments that we don’t defend well enough that cost us three points. It was really like a war of attrition. You’re relying on moments, and we had two really good moments for our goals. Those were two moments of quality that put us in front, and those were the difference between the teams at that moment in time, and we should have seen the game out to take all three points.”


Referee Hardie had pointed to the spot instantly when James Penrice was brought down by Michee Efete with Hearts cruising from a James Wilson double. But he was called to have another look and changed his decision.

Article continues below

Critchley said: “The referee gives a foul, and the initial contact might be outside the box but it clearly carries on inside the box, so it’s a penalty. He gives the foul, then looks at the screen and gives a free kick.

“The contact carrying on into the box means it is a penalty. I thought we had cleared that up after the cup final, but clearly not. The extra time comes from the VAR fiasco. There were eight minutes, which there shouldn’t have been, but we still need to see the game out.”

Follow Daily Record:


Hearts FCRoss County FCNeil CritchleyScottish Premiership
reach logo

At Reach and across our entities we and our partners use information collected through cookies and other identifiers from your device to improve experience on our site, analyse how it is used and to show personalised advertising. You can opt out of the sale or sharing of your data, at any time clicking the "Do Not Sell or Share my Data" button at the bottom of the webpage. Please note that your preferences are browser specific. Use of our website and any of our services represents your acceptance of the use of cookies and consent to the practices described in our Privacy Notice and Cookie Notice.