Skip to main content
Daily Record

Celtic take VAR row to the SFA as Dermot Gallagher names real reason Johnston cut back 'caught out' officials

The Daizen Maeda no goal against Hibs left Celtic boss Brendan Rodgers fuming after the full-time whistle at Easter Road

Brendan Rodgers has revealed that Celtic have been in contact with the SFA over the decision to rule out Daizen Maeda's second strike against Hibs.

It was a tough afternoon in the capital for the Scottish Premiership leaders as they slumped to defeat at Easter Road thanks to Josh Campbell's double - despite Maeda getting on the scoresheet in the second half. However, things could have been very different for the Hoops had Maeda levelled in the closing stages at Easter Road.


Alistair Johnston rushed to keep a pass from Nicolas Kuhn from going out for a goal kick - and would square the ball for the goalscorer to find the net again. However, Alan Muir in the VAR room would step in to overrule the on-field referee Steven McLean and chalk off the goal - after the man in the middle awarded the goal.


Alistair Johnston makes contact with the ball

Rodgers fumed after the full-time whistle with images appearing to show no clear view of the ball trickling out before Johnston's cross - which would limit VAR's ability to intervene. Asked by Sky Sports if there had been any contract with Scottish football's governing body over the decision, Rodgers said: "I think the club have had that.

Article continues below

"There is obviously a process, so between the club and the SFA we will speak but there is not a great deal we can do about it now. But at this point today, there is nothing conclusive. I think all the images we have seen prove that."

Referee Steven McLean confirms the ball was out of play in the build up to Daizen Maeda's second goal after a VAR check
Referee Steven McLean confirms the ball was out of play in the build up to Daizen Maeda's second goal after a VAR check (Image: SNS Group)

Former Premier League whistler Dermot Gallagher confessed that the VAR team could not find an angle where the whole ball is out, backing up the Celtic boss on Sky Sports' Ref Watch. He said: "Well, the assistant couldn't tell for two reasons. A) He's caught out by the speed of the move for a start. And secondly, because Johnston's body covers where the ball actually is, so it's a really, really tough call.

Article continues below

"So the VAR has to look and be convinced that the whole ball is over the line, which bearing in mind how big the ball is, that's a big, big call. But they said it was out."

Follow Daily Record:


Scottish Football AssociationCeltic FCVARScottish PremiershipBrendan RodgersHibernian FCDaizen MaedaAlistair Johnston
reach logo

At Reach and across our entities we and our partners use information collected through cookies and other identifiers from your device to improve experience on our site, analyse how it is used and to show personalised advertising. You can opt out of the sale or sharing of your data, at any time clicking the "Do Not Sell or Share my Data" button at the bottom of the webpage. Please note that your preferences are browser specific. Use of our website and any of our services represents your acceptance of the use of cookies and consent to the practices described in our Privacy Notice and Cookie Notice.